Rolland Griffiths of Johns Hopkins University has led a world first full-scale clinical trial which shows that psilocybin, the active ingredient of magic mushrooms, is able to alleviate depression and anxiety in patients suffering from terminal cancer. The study was published in the Journal of Psychopharmacology.
Patients faced with the prospect of death very often suffer from mood and anxiety disorders (around 40% of patients). Current therapies have not been very successful in treating these disorders. The exception to these are therapies which take an existential approach – a style of psychotherapy which deals with how patients develop meaning in their life, rather than treating dysfunctional cognitions or behaviours. This is where magic mushrooms come in, as they have be shown to inspire mystical experiences in patients. These mystical experiences help patients establish meaning in their life whilst facing the the prospect of death, helping to alleviate their anxiety and mood disorders.
There were 52 participants, half the participants received a high-dose (22mg/70kg) of psilocybin while the control group received a low, non-active dose (1mg/70kg). Five weeks later, the groups were swapped.
Participants were measured for levels of anxiety, depression and other attributes, such as level of spirituality, positive behaviours, attitudes and moods. They were measured before therapy, after the first therapy session, after the second therapy session, and again six months later.
Five weeks after the first session, the patients who took the high dose had lower levels of depression and anxiety and higher rates of remission, than patients who took the non-active dose (see panel A and C of figure below). This effect was still present after 6 months!
If you now look to panel B and D, you will see the effects of the cross-over, i.e. the group who first took the low dose, now takes the high dose and undergoes therapy. It shows that after taking the high dose, this group also had remission rates equal to that of the first high dose group.
Six months after both treatments the remission rates remain low in both groups.
Interpretation of Results
What have we Learnt?
Earlier this year, an open-label pilot study appeared to show that psilocybin reduced depression in patients for up to three months after a single dose. However this study was lacking a control group and only had 12 participants – far too small a sample to generalise to the wider population.
The current study helps fill this gap and shows that psilocybin is able to decrease depression after a single dose. However, this was in cancer patients, so no matter how much we want to, we must not generalise this result to depression in general. It may be that the type of depression of a terminal patient is much different to that of the general population. This is supported by the fact that cancer patients with depression respond less favourably than other depressed patients to traditional cognitive and behavioural therapies – hence the need for an existential type therapy.
It also seems that a single dose of psilocybin sustains it therapeutic effects for up to six months. If this is the case, it is revolutionary! I mean pharmaceutical companies are going to hate it, because they make so much money from the chronic dosing of anti-depressant and anxiety medications, but, imagine the impact this would have on the quality of life of terminal cancer patients living with depression! They most likely are already suffering from considerable symptoms without having to add the extra side-effects associated with antidepressants and anxiolytic medication.
Flaws in the study
The current study has a pretty big flaw. For some reason they decided it was a good idea to do a cross-over design, meaning that every patient got a high dose of psilocybin. This means that there is no control group to properly assess if the long-term effects are actually due to psilocybin therapy. It seems logical that it is due to the therapy, but in science we cant afford to make such assumptions. It may be that these patients would have naturally got better over time, as is what happens with a lot of people with depression who undergo no therapy at all. It may be that the two therapy sessions on their own, without psilocybin were enough to create long-lasting change. Unfortunately the study design does not allow us to properly tease apart these variables, and alas, must be left for another study.
Other possible confounds including the impossibility of creating a true placebo due to the highly noticeable perceptual effects of psilocybin – i.e. the expectency effect. For example, when people notice they are tripping and their therapists face starts contorting into a devil-like creature, they may start inferring with confidence that they have been given psilocybin, and thus the placebo effect is stronger. For myself, I don’t consider this a placebo effect as it is inherent to the drug experience itself, but other purists disagree as they believe it is not due to the hypothesised mechanism of the drug – i.e. by inducing existential insight.
The final word
The acute effects that psilocybin has on both depression and anxiety are impressive, with remission rates around 60%, whilst normal therapies show remission rates around 30%. And this was after A SINGLE DOSE. This could have dramatic effects on the quality of life for terminal cancer patients, and if these effects generalise to all populations suffering from mood disorders, this could revolutionise psychiatry. We cant ignore the therapeutic potential of psychedelic drugs anymore – the next wave of psychedelic drugs as therapeutics is just around the corner.